New York's snowbirds, super-rich could stymie attempts to seal Florida borders

A Florida Beach Getty Images | Getty Images

NEW YORK CITY – New York has bad news for the governor of Florida. Ron DeSantis: The snow bird has flown out of the stable.

To keep coronavirus carriers away from the epicenter of the outbreak, DeSantis ordered mandatory quarantines on Monday for passengers arriving by land and air from Empire State, Connecticut and New Jersey.


However, however he tries to stop the alleged influx of New Yorkers to Florida in the middle of the corona virus, not only has almost all air traffic from airports in the New York area come to a standstill, but also the New Yorkers I want to be in Florida now and I am probably already there. Those who still want to leave will almost certainly find a way to circumvent his potentially illegal attempt to block her – some with the private jet.

“I’m here,” a New York financial service provider told POLITICO, seeking anonymity because his company hadn’t authorized him to speak to the press. “My wife lived [in Boca Raton, Fla.] in the winter. I go every weekend. I came down … a few weeks ago. The whole thing is just crazy. “

On the other hand, there are New Yorkers like Carl Weisbrod, New York’s former planning chairman who owns an apartment in Miami Beach but feels more secure in New York, where the city’s mayor and governor shows more leadership on this issue than their florid counterparts.

DeSantis “hesitated on his responsibility to close beaches and block Florida, where he unnecessarily unmasked the state with the largest percentage of vulnerable people, people over 65,” said Weisbrod.

Even so, in the past few days when New York City has become the Wuhan of the United States, DeSantis has attempted to block residents’ passage south, and has joined a part of the conservative class that sees New York’s epicenter status as evidence of dirty liberal ones Ways.

On Monday, long after the coronavirus had raised its head in Sunshine State, the Republican governor issued an order that anyone arriving from New York be quarantined for two weeks. That seemed reasonable to some New Yorkers. But then he went on and asked the National Guard to get information from every passenger boarding a New York flight and hand it over to the local authorities.

Florida residents who may have traveled to New York in the past three weeks and anyone who has driven rather than flown are expected to abide by the 14-day quarantine, but to their honor.

All of these seem pyrrhical by numbers, possibly unconstitutional, and certainly difficult to enforce.

“The whole thing is just a ridiculous trick, and if you arrive by car, there is no limit,” said the financial services provider.

“First of all, will he put up roadblocks?” Asked Weisbrod.

Florida has long been the top spot for New York refugees – a recent study showed that over 21 percent of people who moved from New York went to Florida over a seven-year period. Their average income was $ 90,310.

Those with larger funds often share the difference – either on weekends like the financial services provider, or south in early winter and back in spring.

“There are no doubt tens of thousands, if not more, of retired New Yorkers who are now in their usual seasonal Florida vacation and planning to return for Easter,” said E.J. McMahon, who led the transplant study.

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, with According to FlightAware data, there has been a significant decrease as only a few dozen daily flights from the four commercial airports to New York fly to Orlando.

Scheduled departures from the port from March 20 to 24 Authorities airports – including LaGuardia, John F. Kennedy International, Newark Liberty International and Stewart International – to Orlando ranged from 56 to 61 flights a day. Actual departures responsible for cancellations ranged from 45 on March 20 to 34 on March 24.

The port authority said passenger traffic fell 85 percent from last March.

With or without a New Yorker, Covid-19 is in Florida to stay. It is spreading rapidly in Florida’s two most populous regions, the counties of Miami-Dade and Broward, which is partly due to the influx of New Yorkers who handle orders for home stays.

“Honestly, I don’t think it’s relevant – because nobody flies voluntarily,” said Kathy Wylde, president of Partnership for New York City. a group of companies. The exception, of course, is the handover, which is not part of the economy class shuffling through airports that DeSantis is now using armed forces to monitor.

According to Wylde, the state’s upper crust – and especially that of New York City – has withdrawn into second homes in Connecticut, the Hamptons or Florida, said Wylde.

“I wouldn’t know how to honestly quantify it – it’s a small spectrum of the population that has the luxury [to fly privately]However, a significant number have told me that they were surprised to find that they can and do operate their hedge fund, private equity firm, or office remotely, “she said.

However, enforcing restrictions on these incoming flights might not be a top priority, Wylde suspected, especially given DeSantis’ trips to New York last year aimed at attracting some of these top earners to move their businesses to his state.

The perceived senselessness of the company’s effectiveness is not lost to the New York governor, a Democrat, who was one of the loudest voices in the coronavirus response and has a national platform to address it.

Cuomo, who chastised youngsters who spent spring vacation on beaches in the southern states as “unintelligent and ruthless” last week, almost stays out of the DeSantis drama.

During press events this week, he refused two questions about whether New York City residents should stay to avoid infection in other regions. Instead, he turned to his health commissioner, Howard Zucker, who generally replied that people everywhere in the state or country should follow the guidelines on social distance.

When asked again on Thursday, Cuomo did not notice whether the Florida order was appropriate or possibly caused by his own strict home stay policy.

“DR. Zucker’s position is that it is not necessary and I would agree with Dr. Zucker,” he said, and went on.

Dana Rubinstein reported from New York, Anna Gronewold from Albany, New York, and Arek Sarkissian from Tallahasse, Florida. Lorraine Woellert reported from Washington.

Leave a Comment